We work very hard to make sure that your order is accurate, fresh, and shipped out as quickly as possible. If you'd like to share your experience with other potential customers we'd really appreciate it! And if something wasn't perfect, please contact us and give us a chance to make it right. Thanks again for ordering from us, thanks for sharing your experience, and welcome to the "family"!
Product Reviews
Showing reviews 1-10 of 730 | Next
-
Perfection!
Posted by Linda on 15th Jun 2026
It was so cool to get something from CandyMafia that I couldn't buy anywhere else. Thank you so much for my Pink Lemonade Jolly Ranchers!
-
Amazing!!!!
Posted by Unknown on 29th May 2026
This place is great! I look forward to more freeze dried peeps in the future.
-
Return Customer since!.
Posted by Jes on 6th May 2026
I have been ordering from Candy Mafia since Oct. 2023. In that time, I always forget to leave a review! I order several bags, every couple 2-3 months. My last order came a bit "disheveled," upon arrival, at no fault of Candy Mafia. Even though It was a shipping issue, CM made it up to me, even when they didn't have to-it was "above & beyond," customer service! Since I always forget to post a review, I'm going to start leaving one when I make my order. Absolutely 10/10 customer service, & they take pride in their business & products.
-
Raspberry Lifesavers Rule
Posted by Unknown on 5th May 2026
Got an assortment bag at the market and discovered I loved the raspberry best out of the assortment. Candy Mafia let me buy bags of JUST the raspberry flavor and that is awesome.
-
Will purchase again.
Posted by WYTONIA on 3rd May 2026
I absolutely love these candies. Brings back good childhood memories. Looked for these everywhere, Thank you for the memories.
-
Candy Mafia is legit!
Posted by Alycia on 28th Apr 2026
Ordered bulk mentos for an event. Product was delivered on time, packaged well and the mentos were fresh and tasty. Will definitely be ordering from Candy Mafia again!
-
Excellent Customer service
Posted by JODI on 19th Apr 2026
Hello I ordered some cherry lifesavers that are hard to get. CandyMafia continued to track my order and respond to every email when looking for my order. When my order finally came in they were very quick with shipping my product out. I HIGHLY recommend CandyMafia and I will order from them again.
-
Fabulous company!
Posted by Pat D. on 14th Apr 2026
I had to email customer service regarding my order. They responded very quickly and were incredibly helpful! My order was perfect and I can’t wait to order again!! Thank you so much!
-
EXCELLENT CUSTOMER SERVICE
Posted by Unknown on 11th Apr 2026
Hello first time ordering from this site candy mafia they have a customer for life excellent customer service regarding my candy in back order and they kept me updated on when my order would be filled. Will order again from them
-
A Legitimate, High-Quality Small Business—Buy with Confidence!
Posted by Dan on 11th Apr 2026
Let’s face it: ordering from a new online company can make anyone a little apprehensive. In today’s world, where prices for everyday essentials are higher than ever, treating yourself or a loved one to specialty candy is a luxury. When you spend your hard-earned money, you want to know the business is legitimate and that you'll actually receive what you paid for.
I am thrilled to report that Candy Mafia is the real deal. They are a wonderful, honest small business that truly delivers.
I recently took a chance and placed a large order with them, and they exceeded my expectations on every front. If you are on the fence about shopping here, rest assured you are in great hands. Here is why:
✅ 100% Reliable: They delivered exactly what I ordered without any issues. It is incredibly refreshing to find an online retailer you can genuinely trust.
✅ Incredible Freshness: There is nothing worse than ordering candy only to receive a stale batch. My order was perfectly fresh, soft, and absolutely delicious.
✅ Hard-to-Find Selections: I ordered a massive batch of the extra-large Tootsie Pops in chocolate-flavor only. They nailed the specific request perfectly.
Their product quality and service are so outstanding that I am already placing a second order today—this time, a huge batch of orange Tootsie Pops to brighten a dear friend's day.
Showing reviews 1-10 of 730 | Next
Loading... Please wait...

